You Can Call It a “Licence”… But the Code Still Applies.

mdillon71_A_dramatic_aerial_scene_of_a_hot_air_balloon_operat_4d4a14a5-4073-4c00-a7ca-633e7fdc0367_3

Case Review: Work Health Authority v Outback Ballooning Pty Ltd [2019] NTSC 55

Outback Ballooning, an Alice Springs hot air balloon operator, faced a tragic incident during pre-flight preparations. A passenger’s scarf was drawn into an inflation fan, leading to fatal injuries. The company was subsequently charged under Northern Territory Work Health and Safety (WHS) laws.

The Problem

The core tension? Outback Ballooning argued that federal aviation laws ‘covered the field’ of safety, implying they shouldn’t also be subject to Territory WHS regulations. Their stance was, essentially, that compliance with aviation-specific rules meant general workplace safety laws didn’t apply.
 
However, the High Court saw it differently. They clarified that Commonwealth aviation laws, which focus on air navigation safety, can and do coexist with Territory WHS laws, which govern general workplace safety. The Court emphasized that complying with one set of regulations does not exempt a business from its obligations under another.

The Outcome

Specifically, the High Court ruled that the operation of the inflation fan was a workplace activity subject to WHS duties. The argument that federal law exclusively governed all aspects of their operation, including ground-based activities, did not hold up.

 

  • High Court allowed the Work Health Authority’s appeal.
  • Outback Ballooning pleaded guilty to WHS breaches.
  • Fined $130,000 plus costs.

The Lesson for Franchisors

Don’t assume that industry-specific regulations (whether aviation, franchising codes, or other sector-specific rules) provide a shield against broader legal obligations like WHS. Your primary regulator’s rules are not a ‘get out of jail free’ card for general safety or employment duties.

Franchisors must ensure that all aspects of their operations, including seemingly routine equipment use, are assessed against all relevant safety standards, not just those specific to their niche.

 

https://classic.austlii.edu.au/au/cases/cth/HCA/2019/2.html

If you’re reviewing franchise documents or unsure whether the disclosure stacks up — it’s worth getting clarity early.

We can walk you through it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Book a free phone consult